PayPal Unauthorized Transaction – Seller Protection Evidence Packet
PayPal Seller Protection needs online, verifiable tracking with a delivered status and date, to an address matching the Transaction Details page.
- ✓ Online, verifiable tracking number.
- ✓ 'Delivered' status and delivery date.
- ✓ Address matching Transaction Details (at least city/state or ZIP).
- ✓ Signature confirmation recommended for $750+ orders.
Step 1 · Instant dispute triage
Visa measures CE 3.0 age from this date.
Visa 10.4 · Other Fraud – Card-Absent Environment
Cardholder says they did not authorize a card-not-present transaction. Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 can remedy this dispute when the cardholder has qualifying undisputed history with you.
PayPal: Each file must be less than 10 MB (50 MB total per API call).
Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 rules
| Visa CE 3.0 requirement | What it means |
|---|---|
| Rule 1 · Prior history | At least 2 prior transactions on the same payment credential, with no fraud reports or fraud disputes. (A prior non-fraud dispute does not disqualify.) |
| Rule 2 · Aging window | Both prior transactions 120–365 days before the dispute. |
| Rule 3 · 2-of-4 match | At least 2 of: customer account/login ID, delivery address, IP address, device ID/fingerprint — matching across all three transactions. |
| Rule 3 · Mandatory anchor | One of the matched elements must be IP address or device ID/fingerprint. Account ID + shipping address alone does not qualify. |
| Item descriptions | Describe the merchandise or services for the disputed and both prior transactions. |
| Scope | Visa reason code 10.4 (Other Fraud – Card-Absent Environment) only. |
Source: Visa, Evolution of Compelling Evidence — Merchant FAQ. Stripe applies the same rule as 120–364 days and also accepts customer email as a secondary element.
Evidence required for 10.4: Other Fraud – Card-Absent Environment
- Visa CE 3.0: two prior undisputed, non-fraud transactions on the same payment credential, 120–365 days before the dispute.
- Visa CE 3.0: at least two matching data elements across all three transactions (account/login ID, delivery address, IP address, device ID/fingerprint), one of which must be IP address or device ID/fingerprint.
- Description of the merchandise or services for the disputed and prior transactions.
- AVS and CVV2 match results returned at authorization.
- 3-D Secure authentication result (ECI / CAVV) if the payment was authenticated.
- Checkout IP address and its approximate location compared with the billing/shipping address.
- Device ID or device fingerprint, and customer account/login ID.
- Proof of delivery to the cardholder's billing or verified address, or proof of digital access by the cardholder.
Source: Visa: Evolution of Compelling Evidence — Merchant FAQ (Mar 2023)
PayPal upload rules
- Accepted: JPG, JPEG, GIF, PNG, PDF.
- Each file must be less than 10 MB (50 MB total per API call).
- Seller Protection proof of delivery: online, verifiable tracking; delivery date and 'delivered' status; recipient address matching the Transaction Details page, showing at least city/state or ZIP.
- Unauthorized Transaction: proof the item was shipped no later than two days after PayPal notified you.
- Signature confirmation: was required for transactions of $750 USD or more; PayPal now lists it as recommended, not mandatory, for transactions after 26 Jan 2026.
Processor upload limits
| Processor | Per file | Combined | Pages | Types | Our target |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe | — | 4.5 MB | < 50 (MC 19) | pdf, jpeg, png | 4 MB |
| Shopify Payments | 2 MB | 4 MB | < 50 per PDF | pdf, jpeg, png | 1.8 MB |
| PayPal | 10 MB | 50 MB | — | pdf, jpeg, png, gif | 4 MB |
| Square | 5 MB | — | — | pdf, jpeg, png, tiff, heif | 4 MB |
| WooPayments (WooCommerce)not published | — | 4.5 MB | < 50 (MC 19) | pdf, jpeg, png | 4 MB |
| Braintree | 4 MB | 5 MB | — | pdf, jpeg, png | 3.8 MB |
| Adyen | 2 MB | — | — | pdf, jpeg, tiff | 1.8 MB |
| Authorize.Netnot published | 2 MB | — | — | pdf, jpeg, tiff | 1.8 MB |
Frequently asked questions
Does PayPal still require signature confirmation over $750?
PayPal's help center says signature confirmation for transactions of $750 USD or more is recommended but no longer mandatory for transactions after 26 January 2026. Older transactions still need it.
What file sizes does PayPal accept?
JPG, GIF, PNG and PDF, each less than 10 MB.