ChargebackBinder

Friendly Fraud Chargeback Evidence Packet

Friendly fraud is a real cardholder disputing a real purchase. Prior history (Visa CE 3.0), verification results and delivery proof are the core of the response.

Step 1 · Instant dispute triage

Visa measures CE 3.0 age from this date.

Visa 10.4 · Other Fraud – Card-Absent Environment

Cardholder says they did not authorize a card-not-present transaction. Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 can remedy this dispute when the cardholder has qualifying undisputed history with you.

Stripe: Combined size of all evidence files must not exceed 4.5 MB.

Visa CE 3.0 · 3-order matrix

ElementPrior order #1Prior order #2Disputed order (from Step 2)
Date—
Customer account / login ID
Delivery / shipping addressenter in Step 2
IP addressanchorenter in Step 2
Device ID / fingerprintanchorenter in Step 2
Item descriptionenter in Step 2
Same card, no fraud report

⛔ CE 3.0 NOT MET — FALLBACK TO STANDARD 10.4 REPRESENTMENT

  • FAIL Rule 1 · 2 prior undisputed transactions: Prior order #1 has no date; Prior order #2 has no date.
  • FAIL Rule 2 · 120–365 day window: Prior order #1: date missing; Prior order #2: date missing — must be 120–365 days before the dispute.
  • FAIL Rule 3 · 2-of-4 match with IP/device anchor: Only 0 of 4 elements match across all 3 orders; at least 2 are required.
  • FAIL Item descriptions: 3 transaction(s) missing an item description (Visa requires it).

Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 rules

Visa CE 3.0 requirementWhat it means
Rule 1 · Prior historyAt least 2 prior transactions on the same payment credential, with no fraud reports or fraud disputes. (A prior non-fraud dispute does not disqualify.)
Rule 2 · Aging windowBoth prior transactions 120–365 days before the dispute.
Rule 3 · 2-of-4 matchAt least 2 of: customer account/login ID, delivery address, IP address, device ID/fingerprint — matching across all three transactions.
Rule 3 · Mandatory anchorOne of the matched elements must be IP address or device ID/fingerprint. Account ID + shipping address alone does not qualify.
Item descriptionsDescribe the merchandise or services for the disputed and both prior transactions.
ScopeVisa reason code 10.4 (Other Fraud – Card-Absent Environment) only.

Source: Visa, Evolution of Compelling Evidence — Merchant FAQ. Stripe applies the same rule as 120–364 days and also accepts customer email as a secondary element.

Evidence required for 10.4: Other Fraud – Card-Absent Environment

  • Visa CE 3.0: two prior undisputed, non-fraud transactions on the same payment credential, 120–365 days before the dispute.
  • Visa CE 3.0: at least two matching data elements across all three transactions (account/login ID, delivery address, IP address, device ID/fingerprint), one of which must be IP address or device ID/fingerprint.
  • Description of the merchandise or services for the disputed and prior transactions.
  • AVS and CVV2 match results returned at authorization.
  • 3-D Secure authentication result (ECI / CAVV) if the payment was authenticated.
  • Checkout IP address and its approximate location compared with the billing/shipping address.
  • Device ID or device fingerprint, and customer account/login ID.
  • Proof of delivery to the cardholder's billing or verified address, or proof of digital access by the cardholder.

Source: Visa: Evolution of Compelling Evidence — Merchant FAQ (Mar 2023)

Processor upload limits

ProcessorPer fileCombinedPagesTypesOur target
Stripe—4.5 MB< 50 (MC 19)pdf, jpeg, png4 MB
Shopify Payments2 MB4 MB< 50 per PDFpdf, jpeg, png1.8 MB
PayPal10 MB50 MB—pdf, jpeg, png, gif4 MB
Square5 MB——pdf, jpeg, png, tiff, heif4 MB
WooPayments (WooCommerce)not published—4.5 MB< 50 (MC 19)pdf, jpeg, png4 MB
Braintree4 MB5 MB—pdf, jpeg, png3.8 MB
Adyen2 MB——pdf, jpeg, tiff1.8 MB
Authorize.Netnot published2 MB——pdf, jpeg, tiff1.8 MB

Frequently asked questions

What is friendly fraud?

A dispute filed by the legitimate cardholder for a purchase they made, often claiming fraud or non-receipt.